Welcome to Nutley Little Theatre

We Are Back!

Current Schedule

Coming Soon!

Tin Cat Poster graphic

Tin Cat Shoes
Directed by Sarah Gorden

 A madcap odyssey through a wilderness of corporate bureaucracy and crippling human dependencies. Blessed with the can-do American spirit, a troop of dedicated shoe store employees embark on a journey of personal expansion. But when “work is your life” and systems breakdown, all that remains is you, a casino, and the truth.


Lee DeCecco as Lunch/Danny

Arthur Carlson as Narrator/911 Operator/ Rodger

Haley Karlich as Pepper

Orlando Rodriguez as Cheddar

Kayla Torres as Gemma

Richard Frohman as Rex/The Bear/Croupier

Thomas Donohoe– Production Stage Manager

Kimberly Gonzalez– Assistant Director

Warning: This performance uses strobing lights and low-hanging fog effects. 

Coming in June!


Hand to God
by Robert Askins

Directed by Chris Hietikko

A devilish, scandalous and foul-mouthed hand puppet tears apart the balance in a Christian Puppet Ministry youth group – exposing the startling fragile nature of faith, morality, love and how easily blood can flow.  The New Yorker called this lightning-paced comedy “Sesame Street meets The Exorcist.”  In his author’s note, Robert Askins has stated “Our play is big.  When people feel, they feel all the way.  When they cry, they scream.  When they love, they hit.”


         Nikolas Elrifi as Jason/Tyrone                

Caity Brown as Margery                   

Katie Toledo as Jessica                   

David Israeli as Timothy                  

Stephen Mennella as Pastor Greg


Connect with Us

Support Our Theatre

Buy Tickets

Nutley Little Theatre engages Showtix4u to handle ticket sales by phone and through the Internet.

Need Support? Schedule a Call with Showtix4U Customer Service
American Express, MasterCard, Visa, and Discover accepted.

NTL Merchandise

Get your NLT Mask!
50% of proceeds go to NLT
Brought to you by our Sponsors Pretty Handy

Join Mailing List

Get Involved

We Thank You For Your Support!